Moderation Questions
Moderation Questions
8
zs

Moderation Questions

The last iteration of the moderation discussion thread was a complete disaster. Numerous attempts to keep it on topic fa

30 January 2024 at 05:27 AM
Reply...

24457 Replies

8
zs


He won't do that. Mussolini was a dangerous socialist, apparently.


by jalfrezi m

He won't do that. Mussolini was a dangerous socialist, apparently.

I'm sure a month will fly by and it will seem like no time at all before we are again treated to his dulcet tones. I mean, Victor was gone a month, and I barely noticed. I know that you missed him, though.


I did, and so did you if you're being honest. 😉


by jalfrezi m

I did, and so did you if you're being honest. 😉

Like a hole in the ****ing head.


by chillrob m

I think his other comment is much worse, saying that racism is not bad or something to that effect.

Yes, the combination of saying that antisemitism isn't dangerous, that poor immigrants are replacing and ruining society, and that racism isn't bad was not good. You can certainly assign different values to each, but I think most of us would add it up to much the same. I was close to banning him myself for this but CrossNerd got to it first.


i don't lurk in I/P anymore because it's almost as bad as the jordan/lebron thread

but i've never seen any outright racist/fascist stuff written by luciom, only vague allegations of it without any links to where he said such things

i think since he posts about social issues that often align with the right, he gets lumped in as a fascist/racist simply because that is the standard trope

ie there's plenty of people who genuinely think and believe trump is a fascist - despite that he's not even close to being one - i imagine the same is happening with luc

this is not a defense of luc nor trump - but i don't think either are a fascist despite that many in the forum will argue they both are


No rick, you haven't read much of him then.


by rickroll m

i don't lurk in I/P anymore .....

but i've never seen any outright racist/fascist stuff written by luciom,

by jalfrezi m

No rick, you haven't read much of him then.

.


by rickroll m

this is not a defense of luc nor trump - but i don't think either are a fascist despite that many in the forum will argue they both are

Fascism brings to mind cartoon villains for most people. In fact, there were ideological underpinnings to fascism that varied by country and among different fascist groups. And there was a fair degree of intellectual support for fascism in certain countries (and intellectual opposition, of course).

Trump is authoritarian, but I wouldn't call Trump a fascist because I don't think there are any ideological underpinnings to his politics.

I don't think it is important to debate whether Luciom is correctly defined as a fascist or not, but I will say this. If, in the near future, a dangerous right wing ideology (whether it goes by the name of fascism or something else) becomes the prevailing ideology in significant parts of the Western world, I think it is likely to resemble Luciom's beliefs.


by Rococo m

Fascism brings to mind cartoon villains for most people. In fact, there were ideological underpinnings to fascism that varied by country and among different fascist groups. And there was a fair degree of intellectual support for fascism in certain countries (and intellecopposition, of course). Trump is authoritarian, but I wouldn't call Trump a fascist because I don't think

Great post.

Also, lol me, looked up "intellecopposition" thinking it might be a real word. I guess it was just typo/autocorrect for "intellectual opposition".


by d2_e4 m

Great post.

Also, lol me, looked up "intellecopposition" thinking it might be a real word. I guess it was just typo/autocorrect for "intellectual opposition".

LOL. I just corrected the typo.


by Rococo m

Fascism brings to mind cartoon villains for most people. In fact, there were ideological underpinnings to fascism that varied by country and among different fascist groups. And there was a fair degree of intellectual support for fascism in certain countries (and intellectual opposition, of course). Trump is authoritarian, but I wouldn't call Trump a fascist because I don't t

You'd call the current prevailing right wing ideology fairly benign?


by Luckbox Inc m

You'd call the current prevailing right wing ideology fairly benign?

I wouldn't call it benign, but the current right wing spasm doesn't really feel much of an ideology, at least in USA#1.


by Rococo m

I wouldn't call it benign, but the current right wing spasm doesn't really feel much of an ideology, at least in USA#1.

Maybe you miss the part where luciom was advocating killing people to prevent them reaching a majority and be able to change some laws through a democratic majority ….
His constant view of anything not far right being evil far left .

I’m amaze people don’t see luciom as a fascist .
No idea what would it take more .


I’m guessing people want to assume the best in people and assume they can’t possibly be as bad as they come off rather than the Occam’s razor approach about believing what people tell you they are


Maya Angelou, but yeah it's been really obvious for a long time.


by jalfrezi m

Maya Angelou, but yeah it's been really obvious for a long time.

Huh?


by Montrealcorp m

Maybe you miss the part where luciom was advocating killing people to prevent them reaching a majority and be able to change some laws through a democratic majority ….
His constant view of anything not far right being evil far left .

I’m amaze people don’t see luciom as a fascist .
No idea what would it take more .

You missed the entire point of my post.


by chillrob m

Huh?

She was an American poet of some reknown.


by Rococo m

You missed the entire point of my post.

more important to have a good catch phrase than to understand what you are labeling with it


by Trolly McTrollson m

She was an American poet of some reknown.

Yeah, I know who she is but my what he was trying to say it what she has to do with this discussion.

Do you ever actually try to be helpful instead of snarky? Ever even considered it?


by Rococo m

You missed the entire point of my post.

I’m actually happy you say so .


by chillrob m

Huh?

“When someone shows you who they are, believe them the first time”


In 30 days we can get a Lucioum unchained containment thread? That would be pretty wild.


by 5 south m

In 30 days we can get a Lucioum unchained containment thread? That would be pretty wild.

I think this is a great solution that would allow him a thread to complete his agenda but keep the other threads "fascist" free.

PlayBig should suffer a similar fate.

Reply...