Talk About Movies: Part 4

Talk About Movies: Part 4

Somehow threads merged, so here's part 4 of our ongoing movie discussion.

19 October 2018 at 12:58 AM
Reply...

5663 Replies


Earlier posts are available on our legacy forum HERE

by TheOneWhoYawns

Good taste is (to a point) good taste, whether it’s movies, food, art, you name it...

I think of having 'Good Taste' is having a level of sophistication, education and experience.

I dont think it is really possible to just 'buy' your way into having good taste... that description is just a cultural appropriation. 'Good Taste' is independent of financial wherewithal

Good taste is an appreciation for the finer details thru comprehension and experiential perspectives.

It's kind of like the way when an observer passes judgement on someone that constantly uses proper 'Manners' in public... the lessor view is to think that the person is just trying to elevate themselves by acting in a sophisticated method... When in all actuality, using 'Good Manners' in public is a way of showing RESPECT FOR OTHERS.


by MSchu18

has anyone here ever seen this Brian De Palma film?
It's age restricted so I can't directly insert it here.


I've never even heard of it before...


a long time ago....but I don't remember much about it


by Dominic

black Panther are great movies

black panther was terrible, even by the standards of its genre


by Dubnjoy000

Not really. It is mainly seen through a typical liberal academics prism - which I also studied in - and not really accessible for your common movie-goer. Which is fine. And something I accepted years ago. But let's be honest about the nature of this thread.

Yeah, I'm just gonna call this a load of tedious crap. Liberal academics prism - what does that even mean?! Recycling a phrase, empty statement.

Marvel films crop up in this thread, so do foreign language artsy ones. If there's more focus on the less mainstream films, that's because there's plenty of other places to talk about the blockbusters.


by rickroll

black panther was terrible, even by the standards of its genre

no it wasn't...it was a lot of fun. BP2 was terrible, I'll give you that.


from wiki:

Secret Mall Apartment is a 2024 American documentary film directed by filmmaker Jeremy Workman that recounts the story of a group of young Rhode Islanders who built a secret apartment inside the bustling Providence Place shopping mall in Providence, Rhode Island, in 2003, living there for four years until getting caught and charged with trespassing in 2007.

The group filmed much of their activity in the secret apartment with inexpensive Pentax Optio cameras that they purchased at the mall's RadioShack and concealed in Altoids tins.[5] The story of the secret apartment had been urban legend for many years,[6] and the documentary brought together the original 8 participants for the first time in 17 years.

Broken YouTube Link

well I wanna see this


I think most of us here have pretty diverse tastes in films. Is it possible to like or appreciate Satantango and When Harry Met Sally, City Lights and Three Colors: Blue (even Derek Jarmon's Blue), Bringing Up Baby and La Region Centrale, Bad Santa and It's a Wonderful Life (to name two Christmas movies)?

Maybe we avoid a film because it gets a bad review here, but we might also see films we never would have if it were not for a great review here.

I don't think you're a film snob, Dom. I don't think I am either, even if some of you might disagree.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


by Dominic

from wiki:Secret Mall Apartment is a 2024 American documentary film directed by filmmaker Jeremy Workman that recounts the story of a group of young Rhode Islanders who built a secret apartment inside the bustling Providence Place shopping mall in Providence, Rhode Island, in 2003, living there for four years until getting caught and charged with trespassing in 2007.The group f

I want to see it too, especially since I live in RI. The story reminded me of high school when we moved from an old building into a new one. I found a narrow passageway behind the boy's bathroom that led to a space no one knew about where we could smoke pot without being detected by anyone. Never got caught.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


I think film snobs are basically pretentious douchebags. But I know what I like and know what I hate. So I can filter through this thread pretty well. I love movies and watch as many as I can. I especially love older movies and movie history. I love reading the thoughts of all posters on this forum. Most likely consider me a lowbrow movie watcher rather than a sophisticated film viewer. Thats cool with me 😀

And I don't think there are lots of film snobs here. Remember that guy Clovis that used to post here? He's been gone for a while but he is one I would put in the pretentious douchebag category. Most here are movie lovers like me even if our tastes differ. Plus I win every movie draft. Look it up!


[YOUTUBE]yx0HzBiaVn4[\YOUTUBE]

A short film by Bill Morrison whose films Decasia and Dawson City:Frozen Time revive the dead, with their splotches, blemishes, and decay intact. There is really something quite haunting about Morrison's work.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk



by John Cole

I think most of us here have pretty diverse tastes in films. Is it possible to like or appreciate Satantango and When Harry Met Sally, City Lights and Three Colors: Blue (even Derek Jarmon's Blue), Bringing Up Baby and La Region Centrale, Bad Santa and It's a Wonderful Life (to name two Christmas movies)?Maybe we avoid a film because it gets a bad review here, but we might also

Good post, John (except the signature bit). Seems as if I heard an interview with Roger Ebert many years ago. When asked why their review show was so popular, he said that he thought it was because they tried to review a movie within the context of what it was trying to be.

So, something that might not be a great movie from a technical standpoint, for example, still might get a thumbs-up because it succeeded at being a good action flick (or whatever).


Clovis was quite knowledgeable but not a douchebag or snob. come on.


by Dominic

no it wasn't...it was a lot of fun. BP2 was terrible, I'll give you that.

agree bp2 was worse - couldn't even finish it

but those two are by far the worst two marvel films


Please...

Thor: Dark World
Thor: Love and Thunder
Black Widow
Captain Marvel
The Marvels
Eternals

Are all way worse than the first BP movie. That's not including the Sony movies, which aren't part of the MCU, but are still technically Marvel movies.

Venom (any of them)
Morbius
Kraven
Madame Web

Next to any of those, either BP movie looks like Citizen Kane or whatever boring old timey movie you guys think is top shelf.


by Dominic

Clovis was quite knowledgeable but not a douchebag or snob. come on.

Nah, he was both a douchebag and a snob!

How about a movie review! Last night I watched the recent Companion (Max). Ehhhh. It was a fantastic premise but for whatever reason I don't feel it really delivered. Not sure why? I don't want to give any spoilers here because its best if you go in clueless. It had its moments but was basically disappointing.


I just saw Eephus (2025). I would guess that you have to be familiar with American recreational baseball play to really enioy this movie. Which I am and I did. It chock full of baseball jargon, colloquialisms, vernacular, humor, and lore. Two aging middle-aged recreational baseball teams, somewhere in New England, play the last game of the season and probably the last one of their lives. They know that the field that they have regularly played on for years is being demolished the next day by the park service and not to be replaced. The movie consists of the events and conversations they have with each other during the entire game. In that way they reveal some of their personal lives. The legendary MLB pro player, Bill "Spaceman" Lee makes an appearance as a relief pitcher at the age of about 77 . He is famous for his version of the marvelous Eephus pitch which baffled some of the greatest hitters. It may have got its name from a hebrew word (eef us) meaning "zero". The pitch is a "nothing" ball. Not a lot of dramatic events happen in this slice of Americana movie. It is just insight into how you might act with your best buddies when you know that a favorite pastime in your life is ending forever for you.

Mr Baseball might want to see this.


I see that my comment has provoked some strong emotions and responses, which was not exactly my intention, so I will go back to filtering through and enjoying this thread 😉

by Rooksx

Liberal academics prism - what does that even mean?! Recycling a phrase, empty statement.

It means exactly what it means ; it would be the equivalent as stating that the poker world is full of ego. Now you could also dismiss the latter as also being an empty statement if you wish, but I have spent enough time in the the liberal arts world and the poker world to have an informed perspective on both. Anyways...


by Pokerlogist

I just saw Eephus (2025). I would guess that you have to be familiar with American recreational baseball play to really enioy this movie. Which I am and I did. It chock full of baseball jargon, colloquialisms, vernacular, humor, and lore. Two aging middle-aged recreational baseball teams, somewhere in New England, play the last game of the season and probably the last one of

Hell yeah! Is it streaming anywhere?


by Dubnjoy000

Not really. It is mainly seen through a typical liberal academics prism - which I also studied in - and not really accessible for your common movie-goer. Which is fine. And something I accepted years ago. But let's be honest about the nature of this thread.

Alas, all my work here has been in vain. I'm going back to reviewing egg salad sandwiches in the casual dining thread.

by John Cole

... well, maybe not ...

by Dominic

Yep, all of this. I'm like the biggest snob here but I still love Godzilla movies lol

Story checks out. At least it's been true for the past couple of decades...


by Phat Mack

Alas, all my work here has been in vain. I'm going back to reviewing egg salad sandwiches in the casual dining thread.

Lemme know what you thought about my egg salad in the "Whats the deal with eggs" thread in OOT from last week!


Regarding movie "snobby' level talk, I appreciate the group. Wish I had the direct quote, but Amy Nicholson is a writer I looked up to a great deal when I got into writing/podcasting and in an article she mentioned that to become a better writer, young people should increase their life experiences. Put yourself out there, meet people, fall in love, get hurt, find a new profession, apply for a job promotion, expand your appreciation of art by watching a variety of movies, etc. That resonated so deeply with me. When I revisit older movies that I haven't seen since early adulthood it's a completely new experience for me. I love that so much.

As much as I love watching French arthouse films, I also enjoy dumb **** like Michael Bay movies. I understand they're dumb. I understand they're for knuckleheads like me, but I'll keep watching them if he keeps making them. I went on a recent Michael Bay kick just to test out whether I've outgrown them. NOPE. Still love em


Clovis was not a pleasant presence on these forums.


by mrbaseball

Lemme know what you thought about my egg salad in the "Whats the deal with eggs" thread in OOT from last week!

Omw


We're all on the same page here, right? We all know that Pain & Gain is the greatest film of the millennium, right? Right?

Reply...